Overhead vs. Underslung Cranes: Key Differences and Which One is Right for Your Facility

When it comes to lifting heavy loads in industrial settings, cranes are essential pieces of equipment that ensure efficient operations. Among the various types of cranes, overhead cranes and underslung cranes are two of the most commonly used. While they may seem similar at first glance, they are designed for different purposes and applications. Understanding the differences between overhead and underslung cranes is crucial for making the right choice when selecting a crane system for your facility. This article delves into the key differences between the two, helping you understand which crane might be the best fit for your needs.

What is an Overhead Crane?

An overhead crane is a type of lifting equipment that moves along horizontal tracks installed on elevated structures, typically at the ceiling or top of a building. Overhead cranes are often referred to as bridge cranes because they feature a bridge that spans across the width of a workspace. These cranes are commonly used in manufacturing plants, warehouses, shipping yards, and construction sites where heavy lifting is required. Overhead cranes are designed to move loads vertically and horizontally, making them highly versatile and efficient in environments where space is limited or where there is a need for precise control over lifting movements.

One of the defining features of overhead cranes is their ability to lift and move heavy loads across long distances without the need for a significant amount of floor space. The crane’s bridge typically travels along fixed tracks mounted to the ceiling, allowing the operator to lift and position the load anywhere within the crane’s operating area. This type of crane is ideal for applications that require high-capacity lifting, such as manufacturing or heavy industrial processes.

What is an Underslung Crane?

In contrast, an underslung crane is a type of crane system where the crane’s structure is suspended from the ceiling, with the lifting mechanism located beneath the bridge. The key difference between an overhead crane and an underslung crane lies in the suspension method. While overhead cranes typically feature tracks that are mounted on elevated beams or gantries, underslung cranes use a bridge that is suspended from tracks located directly above the load area. This results in a more compact design with the load being moved beneath the crane’s structure.

Underslung cranes are typically used in facilities with limited space or where overhead structural elements are either unavailable or impractical. This type of crane is ideal for smaller workshops or spaces with a low ceiling height, where the added complexity and height of an overhead crane may be too much for the available infrastructure. Underslung cranes are commonly used in industries such as automotive manufacturing, machine shops, and smaller warehouses.

Key Differences Between Overhead and Underslung Cranes

While both overhead and underslung cranes are designed to perform similar tasks, there are several key differences that set them apart. These differences often influence the decision-making process when choosing the right crane for your facility.

Structural Design and Space Utilization

The most obvious difference between an overhead crane and an underslung crane is their structural design. Overhead cranes typically use an elevated track system, which means that the supporting beams or gantries are mounted high above the working area. This design allows for greater freedom of movement and allows the operator to lift and move heavy loads over large distances without obstruction.

On the other hand, underslung cranes rely on a suspended bridge that runs along tracks mounted directly above the load area. As a result, these cranes can be ideal for facilities with limited space or when there is a need for a more compact solution. The underslung design also allows for easier integration into existing buildings, as there is no need for the same level of structural support as an overhead crane. The crane can be installed more easily in facilities with lower ceilings or in spaces with pre-existing infrastructure.

Load Capacity and Versatility

Overhead cranes are generally capable of handling much heavier loads than underslung cranes. Their structural design allows for the installation of more powerful hoisting mechanisms, which makes them suitable for lifting and moving large and heavy items. These cranes are designed to handle various types of loads, including bulky materials, large machinery, and other industrial equipment. Their versatility and high load capacity make them ideal for use in heavy industries, such as steel production, automotive manufacturing, and large warehouses.

Underslung cranes, while also versatile, are typically limited in terms of load capacity. Since they rely on a suspended bridge and are generally smaller in design, they are best suited for lighter loads and smaller operations. They are ideal for smaller workshops, machine shops, and industries where space constraints are more critical than load size. However, it’s important to note that underslung cranes still offer excellent precision and can be used for tasks that require accuracy and maneuverability within confined spaces.

Installation and Maintenance

When considering the installation process for both types of cranes, overhead cranes generally require more significant structural modifications to the facility. The installation of overhead cranes typically involves reinforcing the building’s ceiling or adding custom gantries to support the crane’s structure. Depending on the complexity of the crane system, the installation process can be time-consuming and expensive, especially if the facility needs to be modified to accommodate the crane’s requirements.

In comparison, underslung cranes have a more straightforward installation process. Since the tracks are mounted on the existing ceiling or structural beams, there is less need for heavy modifications to the building. This makes underslung cranes an attractive option for facilities that are looking to avoid significant disruption or when they are operating within a pre-existing space that doesn’t need extensive alterations. Additionally, underslung cranes tend to require less maintenance because of their simpler design, though they are still subject to wear and tear and regular inspections.

Cost Considerations

Cost is another important factor to consider when choosing between an overhead crane and an underslung crane. Due to their more complex design and higher load capacities, overhead cranes tend to be more expensive to purchase and install. The cost of the crane system itself, combined with the potential need for structural modifications, can make overhead cranes a larger investment. However, for industries that require high capacity and versatility, the upfront cost of an overhead crane may be justified in the long term by its ability to handle larger loads and more demanding operations.

Underslung cranes, on the other hand, are generally more affordable because they are designed for lighter loads and require fewer structural modifications. The lower purchase price and simpler installation process make underslung cranes a more budget-friendly option for smaller businesses or facilities with less demanding lifting requirements. However, it’s important to weigh the potential limitations in load capacity and versatility against the cost savings when determining if an underslung crane is the right choice.

Choosing the Right Crane for Your Facility

When deciding between an overhead crane and an underslung crane, it’s essential to evaluate the specific needs of your facility. Factors such as available space, load capacity requirements, and the type of work your business performs will all play a significant role in determining the most appropriate crane system.

If your facility involves heavy-duty operations, such as lifting large or bulky materials, or if you need a crane that can move loads over large distances with precision, an overhead crane is likely the better choice. Its ability to handle high-capacity loads and its versatile range of movement make it ideal for heavy industries where lifting and moving large equipment is a routine part of the workday.

Alternatively, if you have a smaller facility with limited space or lower ceiling heights, an underslung crane might be a more suitable option. Its compact design and ability to fit into tight spaces make it ideal for smaller operations, especially where lighter loads need to be moved with precision.

Ultimately, the decision between an overhead crane and an underslung crane comes down to the unique requirements of your facility and the type of lifting tasks you need to perform. By carefully considering your operational needs, space constraints, and budget, you can make an informed decision about which crane system is right for your business.

Conclusion

Both overhead and underslung cranes offer valuable benefits for industrial operations, but the right choice depends on the specific needs of your facility. Understanding the differences in design, load capacity, installation requirements, and cost considerations can help you make a well-informed decision when choosing the right crane system for your business. Whether you opt for the heavy-duty capabilities of an overhead crane or the compact efficiency of an underslung crane, investing in the right crane will ensure smooth and efficient operations for years to come.

Need a Steel Construction Company in Terre Haute, IN?

Benchmark Fabricated Steel is a premium service provider for all your metal and steel needs since 1971. We offer an array of services and products for commercial, business, and corporation work. Our fully trained team is available for project design, erect drawings, site construction, product procurement and delivery, engineering and consulting, and much more. Benchmark Fabricated Steel is fully accredited by the AISC and the Canadian welding association allowing for the highest quality product to be produced. Our business is also recognized by the Chamber of Commerce and is a fully certified fabricator. All of our products are manufactured by the highest quality of equipment, with an expert and knowledgeable staff. Contact us today to learn more about what we can do for you!

Categorised in: Cranes

This post was written by admin